Vinyl Shirley Temple Dolls of the 1950s: Identifying the ST-12, ST-15, ST-17 and ST-19 Ideal Dolls
On a 1950s Ideal vinyl Shirley Temple, the number after "ST" is the doll's height in inches: ST-12, ST-15, ST-17 and ST-19 are the 12-, 15-, 17- and 19-inch dolls of the 1957–58 re-issue. The mark sits on the back of the head and on the back, sometimes with an N suffix (ST12N, ST-15-N, ST17N).
What the ST marks mean
The ST mark on a 1950s vinyl Shirley Temple is a size code. Ideal stamped the doll’s height in inches after the letters “ST”, together with the company name. The Camelot Dolls collector blog explains it this way: a 12-inch doll reads “Ideal Doll ST12”, a 15-inch doll reads “Ideal Doll ST15”, and the mark is on the back of the head and on the back.
So the first thing to do with an unidentified doll is turn her over, part the hair at the back of the head, and read the mark. Then measure her from the top of the head to the heels. A real ST-15 should come out at about 15 inches.
Auction catalogs often print the mark with a hyphen. Theriault’s, the doll auction house, records one 19-inch doll as “marked ST-19 Ideal”. Another reads “ST-19 Ideal Doll Co.” Both forms are the same mark.
For the bigger picture of where these dolls sit among the composition and later vinyl Shirleys, see Dolls by Era and the general steps in Identify Your Doll.
Size-by-size identification table
This table pulls together descriptions of documented dolls from auction catalogs and collector references. The heights are the catalog measurements.
| Mark | Height | Eyes | Hair and body | Documented original extras |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ST-12 (also seen as ST12N) | 12 in (30 cm) | Sleep eyes | Rooted hair in curls or a side part; vinyl socket head on a five-piece body | Gold star box with a wrist tag and four extra outfits; boxed felt trousers and cap with a leatherette jacket (Theriault’s, Theriault’s) |
| ST-15 (also ST-15-N) | 15 in (38 cm) | Sleep eyes, hazel or brown | Blonde to light brown rooted ringlets; five-piece hard plastic body | Heidi and Little Bo Peep costumes, a signature pin, a wrist or hang tag, a Fairyland Heroine window box (Theriault’s, Theriault’s) |
| ST-17 (also ST17N) | 17 in (43 cm) | Sleep eyes; flirty eyes also made | Light brown side-parted ringlets; five-piece body | Nylon party dresses with a vinyl purse, a signature brooch, a tag and a box (Theriault’s) |
| ST-19 | 19 in (48 cm) | Hazel sleep eyes; some flirty | Ringlet curls; vinyl socket head on a five-piece hard plastic body | Sheer nylon dress with lace trim, a cloth label and a pin (Theriault’s) |
Some marks carry an N after the number. Doll Reference’s list of letter-and-number marks gives ST12N and ST17N as Ideal Shirley Temple marks, and Theriault’s records several 15-inch dolls marked “Ideal Doll ST-15-N”. None of these sources explains what the N meant at the factory, so don’t treat it as a date code.
The same Doll Reference list shows why you should read the whole mark. It gives “ST 17 ME” as a Horsman doll. Not every doll with ST and a number is Ideal’s Shirley.
Dating: 1957 or 1958?
You will see both years, and both are reasonable. The Strong National Museum of Play writes that Ideal switched from composition to vinyl in 1957. It ties the new dolls to Shirley Temple’s new television series and to her films being shown on TV. Auction catalogs mostly describe the dolls as “circa 1958”. The Mountain States Collector calls the 1958 re-issue the event that closed out the decade’s doll boom.
The television link fits that timing. Shirley Temple’s Storybook had its first season on NBC from January 12 to December 21, 1958. A second season followed as The Shirley Temple Show in 1960–61. Camelot Dolls notes that the dolls were made through the early 1960s.
The mark alone won’t narrow the year further. Theriault’s describes a 15-inch doll marked “Ideal Doll ST-15-N” in a sailor dress as the 1960 re-issue in a Poor Little Rich Girl costume, while a Heidi doll with the same mark is catalogued as 1958. “Late 1950s” is a safe label. Give an exact year only when a dated box or paperwork backs it up.
Eyes: sleep or flirty?
All four sizes have sleep eyes, which close when the doll lies down. The 17- and 19-inch dolls were also made with flirty eyes, according to Camelot Dolls. Flirty eyes rock from side to side, and those dolls have a ball-jointed head that can rotate in more directions than the standard one. To check, tip the doll gently left and right. If the eyes slide sideways, she’s a flirty-eyed doll.
Auction descriptions give the eye colour as hazel on several dolls and brown on at least one 1960 re-issue. Look for real lashes above the eyes, and on some dolls painted lower lashes as well.
Hair and face
The vinyl dolls have rooted hair, set in Shirley’s ringlets. Catalogs describe it as anything from blonde to light brown, often with a side part. An original set is uncommon, and auction houses mention it when it survives: one 19-inch doll is listed with “ringlet curls in original setting”.
Shirley’s smile is the most recognisable feature. Theriault’s describes dimples and a “smiling expression with row of teeth” on one ST-19, and modelled teeth with a tongue tip on the 1960 ST-15-N.
The signature pin, tags and box
When a doll still has her original paper and pin, you have the strongest evidence that the outfit belongs to her.
- Signature pin or brooch. Many documented dolls still wear a pin with Shirley Temple’s name. Catalogs call it a “Shirley Temple signature pin” or “signature brooch”. The pin appears with party dresses, film costumes and the Heidi and Bo Peep outfits.
- Wrist or hang tag. A paper tag hung from the wrist. Paper is fragile, so a tag that looks much fresher than the doll and her clothes deserves a second look.
- Dress tag or cloth label. Theriault’s describes a number of outfits as “tagged”. Look inside the dress for a sewn-in label.
- Boxes. Three box styles are documented: a gold star presentation box, the window box of the Fairyland Heroine series, and, according to the Mountain States Collector, a “suitcase-like TV Wardrobe box”. The same writer notes that some packages included eyeglasses for Shirley.
Collectors separate a doll that is mint in box from a doll that simply has her box. Camelot Dolls puts it this way: a mint-in-box doll has never been played with, while a played-with doll can still have her original box.
Outfits you may find on a 1950s doll
Documented original outfits fall into a few groups:
- Party dresses in sheer nylon, trimmed with lace or ribbon bows and worn over an attached taffeta petticoat. One 19-inch doll’s dress has a Shirley Temple banner at the waist, and a 17-inch doll came with a small black vinyl purse.
- Fairyland Heroine costumes, sold in a window box from that series. Theriault’s catalogs a Little Bo Peep with a red straw bonnet and red apron, and a Heidi with a green felt vest and cap.
- Film-inspired costumes, such as a Heidi outfit with a pinafore and laced corset vest, a 17-inch doll’s Wee Willie Winkie look of a tagged plaid taffeta dress, tan jacket and red flannel tam, and the 1960 Poor Little Rich Girl sailor dress.
- Extra outfits for the 12-inch doll. Camelot Dolls notes that Ideal marketed extra outfits for this size. One documented example is green felt trousers and cap with a leatherette jacket; a gold star box set came with four additional costumes.
Telling a 1950s doll from later Shirleys
Ideal brought Shirley back several more times, so check the size before you check anything else:
- 1972–73: a 16-inch vinyl doll, usually in the red polka-dot Stand Up and Cheer dress (Strong Museum). No 1950s size is 16 inches, so a doll that measures 16 inches is most likely from this later issue.
- 1982–83: a series in 8-inch and 12-inch sizes, dressed in movie costumes (Strong Museum). Because this series also has a 12-inch doll, height alone can’t tell it from an ST-12. Read the mark on the head and back.
Camelot Dolls also lists a 36-inch Playpal-size Shirley as the fifth size of the vinyl era, and the hardest to find. It is outside the ST-12 to ST-19 range covered here. You can compare other dolls in the doll catalog.
A quick checklist
- Read the mark on the back of the head and on the back. Look for “Ideal” and ST followed by 12, 15, 17 or 19.
- Measure her height. It should match the number in the mark.
- Check the eyes: do they close, and do they also move sideways?
- Look for a sewn-in dress label, a signature pin, a wrist tag and a box.
- If she’s 16 inches tall, or her marks don’t follow the ST pattern, she probably belongs to a later issue or to another maker.
Questions people ask
Where is the mark on a 1950s vinyl Shirley Temple doll?
On the back of the head and on the back of the body. It reads Ideal Doll plus ST and the height, such as ST-15.
What does the N in ST-15-N or ST12N mean?
None of the sources here explains the factory meaning of the N. Dolls marked ST-15-N have been documented both around 1958 and in a 1960 re-issue, so don't use the suffix as a date code.
Is my 16-inch vinyl Shirley Temple from the 1950s?
Probably not. The 1950s line came in 12, 15, 17 and 19 inches (plus a rare 36-inch size); Ideal's 1972–73 Shirley Temple was a 16-inch vinyl doll.
Which sizes have flirty eyes?
Flirty (side-to-side) eyes are documented on the 17- and 19-inch dolls. All sizes have sleep eyes.